From Wake Forest's 1924 yearbook.

God robes go pretty well with ... all of creation, actually.  Not rainproof, though, so you'd literally better be able to walk on water.  From the Phantasie handbook.

From Nebelspalter, 1915.

Takarabune, the treasure ship piloted through the heavens by the Seven Lucky Gods during the first three days of the Japanese New Year.  From Rockford's 1929 yearbook.

"A man must trust the gods.  There's nobody else."

—Gene Wolfe, Latro in the Mist

From North Central's 1926 yearbook.

If we've said it once, we've said it a thousand times -- "The old ones hear."  From Unknown magazine, 1942.

Goddes of the hunt, Diana, from Wesleyan College's 1934 yearbook.

"The bane of animal worship."  From Awake magazine, 1958.

Here's a precursor to Philip K. Dick's A Maze of Death, in which prayers are heard and answered if and only if they are received through the proper technological channels.

From Woroni, 1975.

Bishamon, Japanese deity of treasure and warriors.  From Rockford's 1929 yearbook.

"Why worship the stars?"  From The Link, 1972.