 |
I Found a Penny Today, So Here's a Thought |
(permalink) |
 |
 |
 |
I saw the documentary "Winged Migration" on DVD, and it got me to
thinking a lot about magic and how breathtaking, uplifting miracles can
become so disappointing (and worse than that -- actually negative, or
an experience of spiritual diminishment) when one discovers the secret
of how the trick works. If you've seen the film, you know what
truly magical moments were caught on camera. Most of the scenes
seem "impossible," so extraordinary are they. I wasn't so much
asking "how did they do it?" (because I knew they must have been in
airplanes and holding cameras!), but more "how could they possibly have
captured so many rare, once-in-a-lifetime occurrences?") It was
one of the most striking movie experiences of my life, and I have seen
a lot of films (well-over three thousand films over the last decade
alone). Alas, I began watching the "making of" featurette on the
DVD, and I was totally devastated. The "secret" of the filmmakers
was far more diabolical than I could have possibly imagined. All
of the magic drained away, and I was left feeling tricked (the bad kind
of tricked -- as in swindled by con-men). When a magician does
something miraculous on stage, you've paid to be entertained and you
delight in being fooled. When a documentary filmmaker dupes you,
it's a whole different story. I found myself feeling outraged
over and over again as I learned about the astonishingly elaborate
methods the filmmakers employed to secure their footage (though they
didn't put strings on the birds' claws and fly them like kites, such a
method wasn't beneath them). I actually had to shut off the DVD
player after the worst revelation -- they crated up the pelicans and
flew them in an airplane to Africa so as to record that leg of the
birds' migratory "journey." I would have far more enjoyed
watching a cartoon about birds, or a LucasArts digital rendering of
birds, because neither would have pretended to be a legitimate
documentary. Of course, it all boils down to packaging, doesn't
it? Had the sham-documentary filmmakers stated upfront that this
film was an artistic depiction of how birds fly, and explained that all
the birds in the film were actors (which is actually quite true, as the
birds had been raised and imprinted by the filmmakers from eggs, then
trained to fly on cue alongside the aircraft and to follow the sound of
the squeeze horn), then I probably would have been quite amazed and
delighted by so elaborate an endeavor! As it was, they presented
a fantastic illusion, then turned around and showed how they did it,
leaving the viewer feeling gullible. Had they been real
wonder-workers instead of con-artists, they would have left the viewer
feeling amazed, not duped.
|