Here's a fairy chopper for slaying giants, from Staffordshire Knots, 1895.  But if you're unsure it's the right tool for you, see How to Believe in Your Elf.

From Scottish Fairy and Folk Tales by George Brisbane Douglas, 1900.

Here's the Old Witch of the Sea from The Story of the Mermaiden, Adapted from the German of Hans Anderson by E. Ashe and illustrated by Laura Troubridge, 1888.

From St. Nicholas magazine, 1896.  This should also be of interest: How to Believe in Your Elf.

From the Syllabus yearbook of Northwestern University, 1896.  See How to Hoodoo Hack a Yearbook.

From Djin-Djin, the Japanese Bogie Man, 1896.

"The fairy lake," from Little Loving-Hearts Poem-Book by Margaret Elenora Tupper, 1882.