From Improvement Era, 1950.

From The Duluth Evening Herald, 1906.

From Baylor University's 1915 yearbook.

For those times one needs to cover one's bases.  From Wizardry III: Legacy of Llylgamyn, The Third Scenario handbook.

From Kerygma and Myth by Rudolf Bultmann, 1961.

"Where are the dead?"  From When A Man Dies by Carlyle Haynes, 1948.

"The great battle between good and evil."  From The Life and Adventures of Santa Claus by L. Frank Baum and illustrated by Mary Cowles Clark, 1902.

As some already suspected, God and Evil both wear short shorts (though Evil calls them "hotpants").  From The Gateway, 1968.

From the University of the South's 1892 yearbook.  See Strange Prayers for Strange Times.

From the University of Toronto's 1913 yearbook.

From The Purple Parrot, 1937.

From The Lighted Pathway, 1982.

From Improvement Era, 1933.

Today's angel and devil at the Ouija board is from Wheaton College's 1924 yearbook.  See The Care & Feeding of a Spirit Board.

A better scan of this one.  From Poets' Wit and Humor by W. H. Wills and illustrated by Charles Bennett and George H. Thomas, 1860.From Poets' Wit and Humor by Wh. H. Wills and illustrated by Charles Bennett and George H. Thomas, 1860.

"The shadow of your life is influencing others for evil or for good."  From The Lighted Pathway, 1962.

From Lighted Pathway, 1965.

From The Body Snatchers by Susan Reed.

For when one needs to cover one's bases: Book of Demons and Book of Life.  From Wizardry III: Legacy of Llylgamyn, The Third Scenario handbook.